chasing this poor source network

SC dismisses petitions challenging Delhi HC order upholding Agnipath scheme

2023-12-03 11:42:36source:xsn

The Supreme Court on Monday dismissed petitions challenging the Delhi High Court judgment which upheld the Agnipath schemefor recruitment to the armed forces.

SC dismisses petitions challenging Delhi HC order upholding Agnipath scheme

“Overall there is nothing for us to interfere,” a bench presided by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud said after hearing the petitioners who said the scheme had left those hoping to apply under the old method stranded.

SC dismisses petitions challenging Delhi HC order upholding Agnipath scheme

The bench, also comprising Justices P S Narasimha and J B Pardiwala, said that it did not find anything arbitrary in the recruitment done under the Agnipath scheme or that it was motivated by any extraneous consideration.

SC dismisses petitions challenging Delhi HC order upholding Agnipath scheme

“There is no vested right here. The High Court has said the government cannot act arbitrarily. But it is not really a decision which is weighed in by any extraneous circumstances or any arbitrary reasons,” the CJI remarked while turning down the pleas.

Explained | Explained: Why are job aspirants protesting against the ‘Agnipath’ scheme?

Appearing for some of the appellants, Advocate Arunava Mukherjee said he was not challenging the scheme but only seeking directions to complete the previously notified recruitment process to Army and Air Force.

He argued that “it will make no difference to the Agnipath scheme even if these people are recruited. Because the Union says it will take 15-20 years for Agnipath to show some effect”.

But the court said nobody has a vested right in matters of employment unless the appointment is made. “Anyway, those people came in. Now we are not going to displace those people…You were people who had to come through the normal process. And they had cancelled it or they didn’t proceed with it as the Agnipath scheme had by then intervened. There is no vested right unless and until appointment is made.”


Appearing in a related matter involving petitioners who challenged their non-appointment after their names appeared in a provisional list for recruitment to Air Force, Advocate Prashant Bhushan said “there was written exam, thereafter physical test, medical exam, everything was done. Thereafter a provisional select list was published showing the ranks etc. Thereafter for more than one year, every three months they kept saying that appointment letters were going to be issued, however they were postponed due to Covid-19, etc.”

He submitted that “in the meantime they did recruitment rallies for the same posts claiming it was for fast-track recruitments to address the demographic imbalance to recruit tribal people, etc”. He added that these candidates had got jobs in BSF and other paramilitary organisations, but had refused as they were told that Air Force recruitment letters will be issued.

“They didn’t say the issue of letters being postponed due to Agnipath,” he said, adding there was the issue of promissory estoppel.


“After a more than 2 year process, you have repeatedly told me that letters are going to be issued…,” said Bhushan.

The CJI, however, pointed out that “promissory estoppel is always subject to overarching public interest”.

Justice Narasimha added that “this is not a contract matter where promissory estoppel in public law was applied, it is a public employment” and that “the question of applying this principle will not arise in this case”.

Most Read 1 Gadar 2 box office collection day 4: Sunny Deol film records biggest Monday collections of all time, nets a total of Rs 173 cr 2 Bigg Boss OTT 2 Finale Live Updates: Elvish Yadav wins Salman Khan’s show, Abhishek Malhan shares message from hospital 3 Happy Independence Day 2023: Wishes Images, Whatsapp Messages, Status, Quotes, and Photos 4 OMG 2 box office collection day 4: Pankaj Tripathi-Akshay Kumar film delivers better Monday than opening Friday, earns Rs 55.1 cr 5 Jailer box office collection Day 5: Rajinikanth film set to cross Rs 350-crore mark worldwide on Independence Day

Appearing for the Centre, Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati said the rallies were held in view of the exigencies of the time.

“There were 11 special rallies. The recruitment took place during Covid times. These were extraordinary times that the institutions were grappling with. The process which the defence forces have carried out then is not a process of pick and choose. We wanted to fill up these vacancies because we needed to fill these vacancies in the defence interest, in the national interest,” she submitted.

Also Read
modi ncc cadets independence day
Narendra Modi Independence Day Speech Live Updates: India now identified ...
Govt SOP for Judges: Do not name officials for court panels
Govt SOP for Judges: Do not name officials for court panels
shivaji statue vandalised in goa
Shivaji statue vandalised in Goa, police initiate inquiry
pm modi
‘Will return to Red Fort next year’: In Independence Day speech, PM Modi ...Advertisement

While dismissing some of the petitions, the court on Bhushan’s request agreed to hear the matter in which he appeared separately, on April 17.